header logo
Vallibel FD
vallible LE
Other
Prince Harry and six others ordered to pay initial £9.5m to Daily Mail publisher
Aug 21, 202608:53 PM
Prince Harry and six others ordered to pay initial £9.5m to Daily Mail publisher
Mobitel inner 1278

Prince Harry and a group of six other high-profile figures have been ordered to make an initial payment of £9.54m in legal costs to the Daily Mail's publisher after they lost their High Court privacy case.

 

The seven claimants, also including Sir Elton John and Liz Hurley, must pay the initial figure by 28 August - and could potentially pay up to £25m more after that in a victory for Associated Newspapers Limited (ANL).

 

The group had sued ANL over allegations of unlawful information-gathering, which the publisher had strenuously denied.

 

On 7 July, Judge Mr Justice Nicklin dismissed the claims and said the public figures had failed to prove the allegations.

 

The judge ruled that he was making an exceptional order to force the Duke of Sussex and others to pay up to £34.5m in costs incurred by the newspaper group because of the way the case had been brought - including unsupportable claims that top executives from the group had lied to the Leveson public inquiry.

 

Prince Harry and the other six claimants have until 2 October to attempt to launch an appeal.

 

Those other claimants are Sir Elton John and his husband David Furnish, Sir Simon Hughes, Sadie Frost, Liz Hurley, and Baroness Doreen Lawrence.

 

The judge also ruled that ANL's costs should be determined on an indemnity basis, which is more favourable to the publisher in terms of the amount it can recover, aside from where orders had already been made.

 

The claimants had insurance to cover up to £16.2m of Association Newspapers' costs in the event of losing the case - but Friday's ruling means the newspaper group could now try to recover up to the £34.5m that it said it had to spend to defend itself. This means the Duke and others could face a bill of some £18m.

 

Justice Nicklin described the potential £34m payment to ANL as "excessive", suggesting the costs for the group will not rise to that extent.

 

The judge said: "I regard a claim for costs in excess of £34 million as, on its face, excessive and as giving rise to real concerns as to whether all of the costs now claimed by Associated were reasonably incurred and are reasonable in amount."

 

But he added he had "decided not to impose a ceiling on Associated's recoverable costs", as it would "be too broad brushed, would risk unfairness, and would be vulnerable to the charge that it was arbitrary".

 

He added it was "striking" that "not a single allegation of serious wrongdoing was voluntarily withdrawn" by the group of seven claimants.

 

He said: "That matters. Serious allegations of criminality or grave impropriety cannot properly be left hanging over individuals in that way.

 

"If a party no longer advances such an allegation, or no longer has a proper evidential basis for advancing it, the allegation should be withdrawn clearly and in terms.

 

"The claimants' failure to do so was not ordinary forensic judgment. It was not a proper or disciplined way to deal with serious allegations. It was unreasonable to a high degree."

 

In a statement released on Friday, the publisher called the ruling " a devastating critique of an attempt to destroy a newspaper and the reputations of its journalists, editors and executives".

 

Friday's decision comes just days after the Duke and Duchess announced their plan to return to the UK, with their children Prince Archie, seven, and Princess Lilibet, five, enrolled to start school in September.

 

During the trial, dozens of people gave evidence including Prince Harry and the other claimants. The Duke of Sussex flew in from the US to attend court in person.

 

Many current and former Associated Newspapers journalists and executives gave evidence denying illegal activity.

 

Sir Simon Hughes told the BBC he was "disappointed" by the judgement.

 

"I am now taking the time necessary to consider both the substantive and the costs judgment and whether to pursue appeals against decisions in either judgment or both," he added.

 

In a joint statement following the judge's ruling last month, Prince Harry and Baroness Doreen Lawrence, another claimant and peer whose son Stephen was murdered in 1993, said: "We came to Court seeking justice and accountability. But we have received neither."

 

"It is a complete and obvious whitewash, but sadly not altogether unexpected", the pair added.

 

ANL had asked for more than £9.9 million as an interim payment ahead of future hearings to decide its legal costs in depth.

 

However, lawyers for the claimants said the interim payment should be just over £7.9 million.

 

Mr Justice Nicklin previously said the claimants would need to pay the interim payment on 28 August.

 

Source: BBC

-Agencies  

Disclaimer: All the comments will be moderated by the AD editorial. Abstain from posting comments that are obscene, defamatory or slanderous. Please avoid outside hyperlinks inside the comment and avoid typing all capitalized comments. Help us delete comments that do not follow these guidelines by flagging them (mouse over a comment and click the flag icon on the right side). Do use these forums to voice your opinions and create healthy discourse.

Comments

0
Comments are disabled

Note: Due to legal constraints, the Ada Derana Editorial team has taken a decision to disable comments on all articles concerning ongoing court procedures.

MostRead
Mobitel 1278
VideoStories
Several areas including Colombo receive heavy rains | Rainfall likely to increase on Nov 14, 15 & 16

Several areas including Colombo receive heavy rains | Rainfall likely to increase on Nov 14, 15 & 16

 President to deliver 2027 Budget Speech tomorrow | Focus on macro picture of Budget – Dy Minister

President to deliver 2027 Budget Speech tomorrow | Focus on macro picture of Budget – Dy Minister

Pilotless passenger drone makes inaugural flight in Sri Lanka

Pilotless passenger drone makes inaugural flight in Sri Lanka

Contempt case against Dilith Jayaweera and 5 others; Further consideration adjourned to tomorrow

Contempt case against Dilith Jayaweera and 5 others; Further consideration adjourned to tomorrow

 Four killed, 70 injured in three-bus collision in Rambewa; Reckless overtaking & speeding suspected

Four killed, 70 injured in three-bus collision in Rambewa; Reckless overtaking & speeding suspected

 Cabinet approves $200mn ADB loan to boost SME Sector

Cabinet approves $200mn ADB loan to boost SME Sector

Colombo flooding examined at DCC meeting;

Colombo flooding examined at DCC meeting;

 Bay of Bengal disturbance may develop into depression; Rains expected to intensify from Nov. 15

Bay of Bengal disturbance may develop into depression; Rains expected to intensify from Nov. 15

Govt. to amend Organised Crime Prevention Bill

Govt. to amend Organised Crime Prevention Bill

 Monks seek pardon for Gnanasara Thero; Urge govt. to curb anti-Buddhist activities in the country

Monks seek pardon for Gnanasara Thero; Urge govt. to curb anti-Buddhist activities in the country

GMOA to stage protest in Colombo tomorrow; Govt reserves right to take action against obstacles – MP

GMOA to stage protest in Colombo tomorrow; Govt reserves right to take action against obstacles – MP

Showers wreak havoc across Sri Lanka; Another low pressure system over Bay of Bengal on Nov. 11

Showers wreak havoc across Sri Lanka; Another low pressure system over Bay of Bengal on Nov. 11

What caused floods in Colombo? Special emergency response taskforce to be set up

What caused floods in Colombo? Special emergency response taskforce to be set up

New bills should empower courts rather than police and politicians -Ex-Justice Minister on Hyde Park

New bills should empower courts rather than police and politicians -Ex-Justice Minister on Hyde Park

Deniyaya Tragedy: Bodies of all victims recovered Another teenager goes missing after boat accident

Deniyaya Tragedy: Bodies of all victims recovered Another teenager goes missing after boat accident

Lassana Flora