header logo
Vallibel FD
vallible LE
Other
Supreme Court clears way for Trump to keep building White House ballroom
Sep 01, 202612:02 PM
Supreme Court clears way for Trump to keep building White House ballroom
Mobitel inner 1278

The US Supreme Court has ruled that construction of a $400m (£297m) ballroom at the White House can go ahead, in a victory for President Donald Trump.

 

In a 5-4 ruling, the justices granted the Trump administration's emergency request, blocking lower court rulings that would have halted construction of an above-ground portion of the project.

 

But Chief Justice John Roberts, a conservative, sided with the three liberal justices to dissent, writing that "construction is likely unlawful" because Congress has not approved the project.

 

The National Trust for Historic Preservation filed the legal challenge, arguing that the president did not have unilateral authority to proceed with construction.

 

Trump demolished the historic East Wing of the executive residence last autumn to begin building the ballroom. The White House has said the project will be "substantially" finished by November and fully completed by August 2028.

 

On Friday, the high court had temporarily allowed construction of the 90,000 sq ft (8,400 sq m) ballroom to move forward while the justices considered the lawsuit aiming to halt it entirely.

 

In Monday's unsigned order, the five justices who cleared the way for construction said lower courts had "likely exceeded" their authority in blocking the ballroom.

 

While the majority did not decide on the legality of the East Wing project, they said the preservation group "lacks standing" to sue the government.

 

They ruled that the Trump administration had established it was likely to succeed in arguing that it would "suffer irreparable harm without a stay".

 

Chief Justice Roberts wrote in dissent: "Today's decision is no victory for the separation of powers."

 

Reacting to the ruling, Trump posted that he was "pleased" the "baseless" lawsuit had failed to halt construction.

 

"We are living in the Golden Age of America, and this Building will be one of the Greatest ever constructed in Washington, DC," he said.

 

Trump has long argued that the White House needs a larger events space, and more recently, that it was important for his security.

 

The Republican president emphasised the need for the ballroom after an alleged assassination attempt at the White House Correspondents' Association dinner in April.

 

But the National Trust for Historic Preservation argued that construction was causing irreversible damage to a historical landmark.

 

Its position stemmed from a declaration made by preservationist Alison Hoagland, who lives in Washington DC and serves on the trust's board of trustees.

 

Hoagland, who says she visits the neighbourhood once a month, asserted that she would "suffer both professional and personal injuries, including to my aesthetic, cultural and historical interests, if a ballroom of the proposed form and scale were constructed".

 

In the dissent, Roberts said the injuries claimed by Hoagland were sufficient to allow the lawsuit to go ahead.

 

The National Trust for Historic Preservation said it was disappointed in the court's decision, but welcomed the "strong dissent" by Roberts.

 

"Each President is a temporary steward of the People's House and does not have the unilateral authority to demolish and redesign it without the approval of Congress," it said in a statement.

 

The ballroom project, along with the helipad being constructed on the South Lawn, are just part of the president's wider effort to transform Washington's cityscape.

 

His plans include the renovation of the Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool and a planned "Arc de Trump" larger than the Arc de Triomphe in Paris.

 

Source: BBC

 

--Agencies 

Disclaimer: All the comments will be moderated by the AD editorial. Abstain from posting comments that are obscene, defamatory or slanderous. Please avoid outside hyperlinks inside the comment and avoid typing all capitalized comments. Help us delete comments that do not follow these guidelines by flagging them (mouse over a comment and click the flag icon on the right side). Do use these forums to voice your opinions and create healthy discourse.

Comments

0
Comments are disabled

Note: Due to legal constraints, the Ada Derana Editorial team has taken a decision to disable comments on all articles concerning ongoing court procedures.

MostRead
Mobitel 1278
VideoStories
32-year-old arrested with a large haul of heroin and ‘Ice’ in Thalawathugoda

32-year-old arrested with a large haul of heroin and ‘Ice’ in Thalawathugoda

 Colombo's drainage system can handle only around 30 mm of rainfall – Mayor

Colombo's drainage system can handle only around 30 mm of rainfall – Mayor

Opposition Leader Sajith criticizes government over handling of severe flooding in Colombo

Opposition Leader Sajith criticizes government over handling of severe flooding in Colombo

 No issues concerning overall fuel supply or distribution Stocks secured until mid-2027

No issues concerning overall fuel supply or distribution Stocks secured until mid-2027

 Election Commission suspends SLFP’s status as a ‘recognized political party’ amidst major split

Election Commission suspends SLFP’s status as a ‘recognized political party’ amidst major split

 Detention period in Organised Crime Prevention Bill to be reduced from 72 to 48 hours – President

Detention period in Organised Crime Prevention Bill to be reduced from 72 to 48 hours – President

Government has not taken decisions harmful to public -- Dy Minister Mahinda Jayasinghe

Government has not taken decisions harmful to public -- Dy Minister Mahinda Jayasinghe

 Court orders freezing of bank accounts and vehicles belonging to Rakitha Rajapakshe for 3 months

Court orders freezing of bank accounts and vehicles belonging to Rakitha Rajapakshe for 3 months

Heroin and 'Ice' haul weighing over 150kg seized from vessel intercepted in southern seas

Heroin and 'Ice' haul weighing over 150kg seized from vessel intercepted in southern seas

 Protest against proposed PSTA and Organised Crime Prevention Bill marches towards Parliament

Protest against proposed PSTA and Organised Crime Prevention Bill marches towards Parliament

 The 3rd International Broadcaster’s Symposium to be held on Nov. 11 & 12 in Colombo

The 3rd International Broadcaster’s Symposium to be held on Nov. 11 & 12 in Colombo

 PUCSL recommends 1.46% electricity tariff hike for October–December 2026

PUCSL recommends 1.46% electricity tariff hike for October–December 2026

 Court to deliver decision on Gotabaya Rajapaksa's foreign travel ban on Nov. 25

Court to deliver decision on Gotabaya Rajapaksa's foreign travel ban on Nov. 25

PSTA draws widespread opposition from civil groups; Several protests planned against the Bill

PSTA draws widespread opposition from civil groups; Several protests planned against the Bill

Parliament heated over no-confidence motion against Speaker; SJB stages protest within the chamber

Parliament heated over no-confidence motion against Speaker; SJB stages protest within the chamber

Lassana Flora